Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started

Derive pleasure from following your trading rules, not from profits

One of the most difficult things in trading is associating pain or pleasure with following (or not following) your trading rules, and not from your day-to-day trading results.

Trading results are random. That is a fact.

For example, let’s say you have an edge that results in you being profitable 60% of the time. This means that you will still lose money on 40% of your trades. Beating yourself up for these losses has zero benefit to you as a trader.

We are battling ourselves

The human psyche is fragile. We are battling our egos.

Sometimes in trading we get more concerned about being “right” than making money. This is why we sit on losing positions, hoping they come back in our favor. This is why we don’t take small losses, allowing them to turn into big ones.

I was stuck in a rut, which I’m working towards getting out of. Today has been a step in the right direction for me. Today my focus is on following my trading rules, not make a profit per se. This is really hard to do. Besides, isn’t the goal to make profits after all?

Associate positive feelings with following your trading rules, not the end results

Accepting that a trade is going against you and cutting it should be associated with positive feelings because you cut those losers early.

No one wants to lose money, and that’s why it’s so hard to associate a positive feeling with taking a loss. Taking losses sucks, and we all wish they were avoidable.

It’s difficult to do this. Losing money hurts. But, it’s important to reframe losses as a cost of running your trading business.

I have to remind myself to be impatient with losing trades. I can’t fear cutting a loser too soon. If trade doesn’t feel right and isn’t going the way I expect it to, it’s okay to cut it.

I have to remind myself to not look back at trades that have been cut loose. This look back bias makes me kick myself for not holding a trade longer. This is detrimental to my future trading performance, because I end up holding losers longer that should’ve been cut the moment they no longer felt like good trades.

I have to remind myself that I can always re-enter a trade if an attractive setup presents itself once again.

Dealing with randomness

Establishing a set of trading rules, and sticking to those trading rules has proved to me to result in more profitable trades rather than focusing on profits alone.

If you have a legitimate edge in the market, a set of good trading rules to follow, then profits will follow as result of disciplined trading.

Advertisement

The return of selling in the stock market

I believe we are about to see heavy selling in the market once again.

We have seen the return of some selling, with the S&P 500 down 4.7% this week as of my writing on May 14th.

Why do I believe this?

Coming into this week, I expected a calm week with usual options expiration (OPEX) week behavior. From my observations, market makers can usually move markets and control price action more strongly some weeks than other.

Market makers can influence markets especially in times when volume is low and volatility is low. This week, the market has seen more selling than usual during OPEX week from my experience.

Not only that, but we haven’t seen the drastic moves in the S&P futures contracts overnight. Last week, it felt like every day we were seeing moves higher after a day of selling off during regular trading hours.  See tweet below:

on moves 5-14-20

The last time I remember feeling like this during an OPEX week was for the trading week ended February 21, 2020 and we all remember what followed over the next month.

What are gamma levels saying?

On May 11, 2020 I noted that $2.2 bn in positive gamma was coming off books this opex Friday.

tweet 5-14-20

Now these options could have been rolled out or closed altogether. We never really know. But I expected much of this gamma exposure to be moved in a manner that would bring us closer to zero gamma.

With all the selling this week, gamma levels have now turned negative across the board according to spotgamma. This is not good if you are bullish equities right now.

spotgamme 5-14-20

While component gamma is still positive, per Squeezemetrics, and DIX signals that Dark Pools continue their buying binge, I can’t ignore headwinds that we are going to face in the next week or two.

squeeze 5-14-20

What headwinds are we faced with?

Will we see a second wave of infections?

What businesses are going to go out of business for good?

How many of the now 36 million lost jobs will actually be recovered?

What will be the recovery time of those lost jobs?

What kind of demand shocks are we in store for over the next year or two?

How far is the Fed willing to go with their monetary policies?

Will the Fed buy equities?

With all of these questions unanswered, it’s very difficult to be bullish right now.

Trading in the Zone – Book Notes

I recently finished reading Mark Douglas’s book, Trading in the Zone. This book found me at an opportune time, as I’ve been going through a rough patch with my trading and especially my mindset while trade.

If there is one book I highly recommend you read as a trader to get your state of mind right, it’s Trading in the Zone. Here are my book summary notes below. Note that my summary notes are not short. It’s over 2,500 words of the best wisdom I pulled out of the book.

Book Summary Notes

Have confidence in trades.

Focus on opportunities.

Fundamental analysis is the study of finding supply and demand of an investment based off fundamental information.

Technical analysis is based off patterns in an investments’ historical data.

Technical analysis is more “in the moment” than fundamental analysis. You react in the moment to changes in prices.

Good traders have rules for entry and exits.

Accept risk before putting on a position and never assume you are correct. Be quick to admit you’re wrong.

Accept the possibility that you will lose money so that you can objectively manage a position.

Good traders aren’t afraid because they have effective management strategies to enter and exit trades.

The four primary trading fears are:

  1. Being wrong
  2. Losing money
  3. Missing out
  4. Leaving money on the table

We blame the market for our losing money.

How you view the market affects the consistency of your results.

You can never know the myriad of ways the market can make you lose money.

Accept that the outcome of a trade is unknown, and that one trade is not a reflection on you as a trader. Failure to accept this leads to costly decisions.

Doing more market analysis will not make you a better trader. Acceptance of what the market is will.

Accept the risk you take on with every trade, and you will no longer be afraid.

Trade without fear, and have rules to prevent reckless behavior.

The market presents you with unlimited possibilities, and this can challenge those not equipped to deal with this fact.

Desires are generated internally, but must be fulfilled externally.

Once we identify a desire we are drawn to fill that desire externally. Denial of this opportunity to fulfill a desire leads to pain.

Accept that trades are a probabilistic outcome, and define how much risk you are willing to take on this probability.

Prices always move. Your entries and exits last as long as you want.

The market will not make you exit a trade. You must do that. Don’t be a passive loser. Actively lose by defining your risk.

Trading gives you ultimate freedom. This can be a curse because you have no structure to follow.

Most of those who get into trading initially struggle to create a set of rules to follow.

That which draws us to trading is the same thing that makes us resist creating trading rules.

Your impulses hinder your ability to trade well for psychological reasons.

You must keep yourself responsible for the way you take profits and take losses.

If you play probabilistic edges, you must be consistent in how you trade them and not get thrown off by a few losing trades.

Don’t get hung up on any single trade.

Adapt to your environment and create rules so that you can adapt appropriately.

Winning early as a trader can hurt your long-term performance.

Trying to “understand why” the markets do something can hurt you in the long run.

Your mental attitude will produce better results than analysis alone.

Trading can be a simple pursuit in which you don’t need a ton of skills, but rather a winning attitude.

Operate from the belief that trading losses are a natural part of trading and should be considered as your business expenses.

We feel pain when reality fails to meet our expectations, especially when they are unrealistic.

Losing traders blame markets for their losses.

You blame markets for your results if you don’t accept the randomness of markets, have rules to protect you against this randomness, and take responsibility of your results.

Your goal is to extract money from the market, and the markets’ goal is to extract money from you.

Markets owe you nothing. Don’t blame them for your losses.

Take complete responsibility of your trading. Otherwise you will view the market as your adversary and you believe that your problems can be fixed by better analysis.

Every entry and exit on a trade is an opportunity for you to act in your own best interest.

You are never fighting the market, because it owes you nothing.

Learning about markets isn’t bad, but it can give you a false confidence that you know what will happen next and ignore the randomness inherent to markets.

Learning more about markets isn’t going to eliminate losing trades. Don’t take losing trades personally.

Accept your losses and you will no longer view market information as painful. You will view it as it is, information.

Our bias to avoid pain makes us ignore or alter information that the market provide us.

In sports there is a more discernible connection between one’s focus and results. It’s harder to see this connection in trading.

Leaving money on the table can be more painful than taking a loss because you know you missed out on a large profit.

Make winning and consistency are states of mind.

Make yourself available to what the market is offering you.

Our biases make us interpret information that is favorable to our own egos, even though it can hurt more in the long run.

Fear causes 95% of the errors you are likely to make.

Think about trading in a way that keeps fear at bay so that you can continue to focus on opportunities.

Let the market unfold and make yourself available to opportunities with a clear mind.

Accept risk and you won’t have anything to fear.

You see what you’ve learned to see, and miss that which you haven’t learned to see.

Every trade is an edge with a probable outcome. Know this to define your risk, and eliminate your fears.

Perceive the market objectively. Don’t project your own feelings on the market.

Your emotional mind links your current state to your most recent trading experiences, which can be painful and create a fearful state of mind.

The “secret” to trading well is four items:

  1. Trade without fear OR overconfidence
  2. Perceive what the market is offering clearly
  3. Stay focused on the “now moment opportunity flow”
  4. Enter the “zone” and believe in an uncertain outcome with an edge in your favor

Great traders don’t let emotions of recent trades influence their process.

To be a consistently successful trader one must learn adapt.

It can take years for most traders to figure out that consistency trumps picking the occasional winner.

The best traders cut their losses without hesitation if the market tells them it’s not working.

The three most costly trading errors you can make

  1. Not predefining your risk
  2. Not cutting your losses
  3. Not systematically taking profits

Thinking that you “know” what will happen next is the cause of most trading errors you will make.

The most effective trading belief you can acquire is “anything can happen.”

Every trader acts on their own belief about what is high and what is low, and collective behavior pattern is displayed in the price at that moment.

Every trade you make is unique from every other trade you’ve made.

Train your mind to think in probabilities, and have actions that you take to deal with these unknown outcomes.

Don’t ever convince yourself you’re right when you enter into a trade. Instead, define the risk.

When you think you know what will happen, you are effectively thinking you know the future actions of every single individual and how they will move prices.

Markets are unique, anything is possible. To ignore this fact is foolish.

Your beliefs are shaped by your expectations. These beliefs cause you perceive market information that confirms your bias, and ignore market information that conflicts with your bias.

Market information that goes against our position is ignored when we find it too painful to acknowledge.

We focus on information that helps minimize our pain, which is destructive to our trading.

We lose out on opportunities when we choose to ignore what the market is telling us.

Our pain-avoidance mechanism shields us from seeing information that is not aligned with our beliefs.

Traders must learn to be rigid in our rules, and flexible in our expectations.

There are five fundamental truths you must accept to think probabilistically:

  1. Anything can happen
  2. You don’t need to know what will happen next to make money
  3. Wins and losses are randomly distributed for any given edge
  4. An edge is an indication of higher probability of one thing over another
  5. Every moment in the market is unique

When you put on a trade, your only expectation is that something will happen. That’s it.

Define a stop loss for every trade. This should be some point where the odds of success are greatly diminished in relation to the potential profit.

Losses are the cost of doing business in the course of finding winning trades.

Each moment in the market is an opportunity to do something on your behalf. You always have an opportunity to:

  1. Scratch a trade
  2. Trade profits
  3. Cut losses
  4. Add or detract from a position

Expectations are beliefs projected into some future moment.

We can’t know what to expect from the market because other traders are always there to enter and exit trades based off their own beliefs about the future.

The only thing you should “know” in trading is what an edge looks like, how much you need to risk, and a plan for taking profits or losses on a trade. You can never know if any one trade will work out.

Don’t have an agenda when you trade. Make yourself available to the opportunities the market makes available to you with a clear mind.

Emotional pain is a response we have when the world expresses itself in a manner opposite of our beliefs.

Don’t expect the market to make you “right” or “wrong”.

Don’t expect to market to go in your favor forever. Establish rules for taking profits.

Gathering more information to predict if a coin will flip heads or tails is silly. Why would you expect it to work in the markets? Remember that every trade is probabilistic.

Every moment is unique, and therefore you will never “know” what will happen next.

Don’t try to change your beliefs. Remove the energy behind that belief, and channel it towards better beliefs.

It’s hard to make new discoveries when your internal beliefs conflict with those discoveries.

The underlying cause of fear in trading is interpreting market information as threatening.

You must believe that every edge has a unique outcome in order to trade without fear.

You must believe you don’t know what is going to happen next.

Train your mind to expect a unique outcome in order to see market information objectively.

Believe that each moment is unique in order to achieve mental freedom while trading.

Trading is a pattern recognition numbers game. Identify patterns for some edge, define your risk, and take profits consistently. Some trades work and some don’t. Don’t take it personally.

Trading is one of the hardest things to do because the more you think you know, the less successful you’ll be.

Manage your expectations as a trader and align your mental environment with the five fundamental truths.

  1. Trust yourself to operate in an unlimited environment
  2. Focus on flawlessly executing a trading system
  3. Think in probabilities – the five fundamental truths
  4. Create a strong belief in your consistency as a trader

Your primary objective as a trade should be to produce consistent results. The way you do that is by following your trading rules with unshakeable confidence.

Consistency should be your primary reason for trading.

Making mistakes will happen until your beliefs are in harmony with your desires and your beliefs are consistent with what works from an environment’s perspective.

Don’t think less of yourself when you make mistakes.

Mistakes should not hold negatively charged energy for you.

Beliefs must be in alignment with goals and desires to eliminate any conflicting energy.

You must create the belief that you are a consistently successful trader.

Don’t make it a goal to guess correctly. Make it a goal to be consistent with your techniques.

Tell yourself, I am a consistent winner because:

  1. I objectively identify my edges
  2. I predefine the risk of every trade
  3. I accept risk and am willing to let go of trades
  4. I act on my edge without hesitation
  5. I pay myself as the markets make profits available to me
  6. I monitor myself for my susceptibility to make errors
  7. I never violate these principles above

To be an objective observer, think from the market’s perspective. There are always unknown forces waiting to act on price movement so that every moment is truly unique.

The typical trading errors are:

  1. Hesitating
  2. Jumping the gun
  3. Not predefining risk
  4. Defining risk but not taking a loss
  5. Exiting a winning trade too soon
  6. Not taking profits on a winning trade
  7. Letting a winning trade turn into a loser
  8. Moving stop too close to your entry point
  9. Trading too large a position in relation to your equity

You can change your identity by changing your desires.

Losses call for larger % returns in order to be profitable. A 50% loss requires a 100% return to become profitable again.

Divide your position into thirds or quarters, and scale out of the position when taking profits.

Take off a portion of a winning position whenever the market presents you with the opportunity to do so.

In a three contract trade, establish a stop loss, and take profits by scaling out of the position one contract at a time.

Scale out of positions to create “risk-free opportunities”. These are positions where you have taken profits to the extent of max loss allowable on the remainder of the position, therefore guaranteeing a break-even trade at a minimum.

Try to achieve a risk to reward ratio of 3:1, which means you risk one dollar for every three dollars of profit potential.

Success or failure of a strategy should be based off a sample size of 20 trades or more.

An edge is merely a snapshot which captures a limited portion of all probabilities.

Be willing to make 20 trades on a strategy before making a judgement of its effectiveness.

Follow your trading rules and focus on the five fundamental truths in trading.

If you can go through 20 trades without allowing your emotions to influence you adherence to rules and probabilities, then you discover that thinking in probabilities is a functioning part of your identity.

Conclusion

Again, if there is one book I highly recommend you read as a trader to get your state of mind right, it’s Trading in the Zone.

Affiliate links are used above. Your purchases help to support the content of this blog. Thank you!

Who are the four kinds of informative traders?

This post is a work in progress and will be updated frequently. Please bookmark page to see updates.

The follow note is based off Larry Harris’s book, Trading and Exchanges.

There are four types of informed traders who operate in markets. Those traders are value traders, news traders, information-oriented technical traders, and arbitrageurs.

Informed traders help prices more informative. Uninformed traders make prices less informative.

Value traders estimate the fundamental values of a particular investment. These are the traders who attempt to estimate the fundamental value of a company, and buy or short a stock based off this.

News traders estimate changes in fundamental values. They rely on value traders properly pricing an investment, and trade based off news events they believe can materially affect the price of an investment.

Information-oriented traders estimate patterns that are inconsistent with fundamental values.

Arbitrageurs estimate the differences in fundamental values. They identify investments which generally correlate. When they notice a divergence in those investments, they short one investment and long the other until the prices converge once again.

 

What are Federal Reserve repo operations?

Repo operations (within the context of the Federal Reserve) are Repurchase agreements and are conducted only with primary dealers.

The Fed purchases Treasury, agency debt, or agency mortgage-backed securities from a counterparty, subject to an agreement to resell the securities at a later time.

It’s similar to having a loan that is collateralized with assets. These assets from the banks have a higher value than the loan to protect the Fed against market and credit risk.

Repo transaction temporarily increase the quantity of reserves in the banking system.

The New York Fed began conducting repo operations in September 2019 to ensure supply of reserves is ample and to mitigate risks of money market pressures near year-end that could affect policy implementation of interest rates.

What is a repo?

Repo is a generic name for repurchase transactions (which can include buying or selling). It is a transaction in which one party sells an asset (such as Treasury Bonds) to another party at a set price and commits to repurchase the same assets from the same party at some future date.

If the seller defaults, the buyer is free to sell that asset to a third party to offset their loss. This is what makes a repo very similar to a collateralized or secured deposit.

How is repo rate determined?

The difference between the price paid by the buyer at the start of the repo and the price received at the end is effectively the lending rate on the repo. This is known as the repo rate or repo interest.

Why are repurchase agreements (repos) used?

Repurchase agreements can serve four different functions for various market participants:

  1. They are a safe investment
  2. Borrowing costs on repos are very cheap
  3. Yields can be enhanced for those holding a large amount of safer assets
  4. They provides a means for short-selling and short-covering

It’s safe because the cash is secured by collateral, which is generally safe assets. Makes it easy for seller of repo to make money back by selling those secured assets.

Yields are enhanced because a party could lend out a high demand asset to the market, and in return they receive cash for cheap which can be used for funding or reinvesting profits.

Why do banks use repos?

Banks will use repurchase agreements (repos) for short-term borrowing. They do this to raise short-term capital and generally use agreements which are very short-term, generally overnight or 48 hours.

The implicit interest rates on these agreements is known as the repo rate, and is a proxy for the overnight risk-free rate.

Repo can be used for many purposes. One such purpose would be as an efficient source of short-term funding

It also allows institutional investors to meet liquidity requirements without having to liquidate long-term investments. The repo market has become an important source of cash for non-banks to meet Basel regulatory requirements.

The World has Gone Mad – Ray Dalio Article Summary

Two months ago Ray Dalio wrote an article on how the world has gone mad with regards to monetary policy. Here is my short summary of Mr. Dalio’s article:

We are currently “pushing on a string”, a phase which Ray says we have never seen during our lifetimes. This is the situation where investors are flush with cash, and would rather invest it, not spend it.

The prices of financial assets have gone up as interest rates have plummeted. Low expected returns aren’t just driving up the prices bonds, but also equities, private equity, venture capital, etc.

Startups don’t have clear paths to profits, so they rely on selling dreams (Adam Neumann WeWork is a prime example) to get people to invest in their ideas. Investment managers are sitting on large hordes of cash and are looking for any place to park their funds, hence the overblown valuations of companies.

Government deficits are large and continue to grow. As a result, governments must sell more debt that nobody is interested in buying because the interest rates on these debts are so low. Central banks end up buying this debt by printing new money. (But don’t say they are monetizing the debt).

Down the road, as pension and healthcare liability payments come due, those obligated to make these payments will be unable to do so. How does this happen? Those institutions have expected returns of 7%, much greater than expected returns in the market in the coming years.

As these institutions are unable to make payments, unfunded liabilities will balloon as a result of suppressed growth. Teachers and governmental employees are those most exposed to this risk.

In sum, money is basically free (because of low to negative interest rates) for those who have money and creditworthiness. Money is unavailable for those without money or creditworthiness.

This contributes further to the wealth gaps we see today. Technological innovations are creating a way for companies to cut jobs further as well. The effects of low interest rate monetary policies are no longer “trickling down” to workers as a result. Thus explains how to we got where we are today.

Who and What are primary dealers?

Primary dealers are trading counterparties of the New York Fed in the implementation of monetary policy. The make markets for the NY Fed as needed, and bid on a pro-rate basis in all Treasury auctions at reasonably competitive prices.

There are 24 banks designated as primary dealers. Well known banks that are primary dealers include JP Morgan, Wells Fargo, Bank of America, Citi Group, Deutsche Bank, just to name a few.

Why do we have primary dealers?

Primary dealers are counterparties who buy government securities and resell them to the overall market. These are banks that have an inside track to buy US Treasuries.

Primary dealers purchase the vast majority of the U.S. Treasury securities (T-bills, T-notes, and T-bonds) sold at auction. They will then resell those securities to the public. Their activities extend well beyond the Treasury market.

Arguably, this group’s members are the most influential and powerful non-governmental institutions in global financial markets.

Where are primary dealers located?

Many dealers are in the US. There are also dealers across the globe, including Japan and Europe that distribute US Treasuries to those geographical areas of the world.

What are the requirements for primary dealers?

Firms must meet specific capital requirements before it can become a primary dealer.

The capital requirements for broker-dealers that are not affiliated with a bank is $50 million. Banks acting as primary dealers need to have $1 billion of Tier 1 capital (equity capital and disclosed reserves).

Prospective primary dealers need to show they made markets consistently in Treasuries for at least a year before their application.

What are the options Greeks?

This article is part of a more broad series of research questions I address regarding Gamma Exposure. Check out this post for more.

Greeks refer to dimension of risk that an options position entails. The Greeks are used by options traders and portfolio managers to hedge different risks to their positions.

Is simple terms, the Greeks are derived based off a pricing model, like Black-Scholes, using inputs: option price, underlying stock price, days to expiration, and risk free interest rate.

The most commonly used Greeks used are Delta, Gamma, Theta, Vega.

Delta

Delta is the amount an option price is expected to move based on a $1 change in the underlying stock.

Calls always have positive delta, between 0 and 1. If the underlying stock price goes up and no other variables change, the price for the call will go up.

If a call has a delta of 0.50 and the stock goes up $1, the price of the call will go up about $.50. If the stock goes down $1, the price of the call will go down about $.50.

Puts always have a negative delta, between 0 and -1.

Gamma

Gamma is the rate of change in delta for every $1 change in the stock price. If delta is the “speed” at which option prices change, you can think of gamma as the “acceleration.”

Options with the highest gamma are the most responsive to changes in the price of the underlying stock.

Gamma is highest for options with strike prices near the current underlying stock price. It is also highest for those options at the money that are closer to expiring vs. those options which are due to expire further out in the future.

Theta

Theta, aka time decay an option buyer’s biggest enemy, and option seller’s best friend. Theta is the amount the price of calls and puts will decrease theoretically for a one-day change in the time to expiration.

In the options market, the passage of time will erode an options value. Time value melts away and does so at an accelerated rate as expiration approaches.

Vega

Vega is the amount call and put prices will change, in theory, for a corresponding one-point change in implied volatility.

Vega does not have any effect on the intrinsic value of options, it only affects the “time value” of an option’s price.

Typically, as implied volatility increases, the value of options will increase. That’s because an increase in implied volatility suggests an increased range of potential movement for the stock.

Conclusion

If you’re trading options, you absolutely must understand those Greeks above and how they impact your trading strategies.

What basic assumptions are made in calculating gamma exposure?

This article is part of a more broad series of research questions I address regarding Gamma Exposure. Check out this post for more.

Note below adapted from SqueezeMetrics White Paper

There are a few assumptions we make when we calculate gamma exposure. These are the following assumptions:

All options traded are facilitated by delta-hedgers. We assume that all orders run through a market maker who owns a book of options.

Call options are sold by investors and bought by market makers. Based off skew, open interest at a strike, and effects of GEX, call overwriting drives the options market for calls. We assume call options are written as covered calls for portfolios.

Put options are sold by investors and bought by market makers. Puts are bought by parties looking to protection their portfolios against a drop in market prices.

Based off skew, the implied volatility of put options is generally higher than the implied volatility for call options.

Market makers hedged deltas continuously. This may not be the case, but the assumption is held for the purposes of gamma exposure.

Possible issues for those assumptions above:

If traders and investors are buying more call options than they are selling to market makers, this would drastically change the calculation of gamma exposure. This would also be true if traders and investors are selling more put options than they are buying from market makers.

Like any signal in the market, the gamma exposure signal could go away as it becomes more known. For that reason, gamma exposure should only be used as one component of your decision making process.